...

Same look, same sound, same idea? How does the UKIPO assess similar trade marks?

A business chooses a name and discovers something similar already exists. The UKIPO does not only ask whether the marks are identical. It asks whether customers would be confused. This matters because choosing a name which later clashes with an existing mark can be expensive. This article covers how the goods and marks are compared and how the factors are balanced.

The basic question: would customers be confused?

An earlier mark is one registered or applied for before yours. Identical marks on identical goods are the clearest form of conflict. If the marks or the goods are only similar, the question is likelihood of confusion. Confusion means that customers would probably mix them up or think that the businesses are linked. A mark reminding someone of another is not enough. The aim is to protect customers from being misled.

Comparing the goods and services

The UKIPO compares goods and services by looking at what they are, what they are for, how they are used, whether they compete and whether they are bought together. For example, toothpaste and a toothbrush are different products, but people often buy them together as a pair so they may be treated as closely related. This matters because goods which customers see as related are more likely to be assumed to come from the same business.

Comparing the marks: the look, sound and meaning

When the UKIPO compares two marks, it looks at three things: how they look, how they sound and what they mean. The marks are judged as a whole, as customers do not pick them apart, but they tend to remember the most distinctive part. How much each factor matters depends on how the goods are bought. Clothing is usually chosen by sight, so appearance matters most. Over-the-counter medicines and things such as leisure club classes are often asked for out loud, so sound matters more.

A balancing exercise: how all the factors work together

No single factor decides it. The UKIPO looks at how similar the marks are, how distinctive the earlier mark is and how similar the goods are. These work together. Less similar marks can still conflict if the goods are very close, and the closer the goods are, the lower the bar is for confusion. If the existing mark is unusual and memorable, more likely to cause confusion. For instance, two fairly different names for almost identical products can still clash whilst similar names for unrelated products are less likely to.

When one mark contains another: names and product names

“Alexander” on its own does not normally conflict with “Alexander Morgan” because both parts of a full name matter roughly equally, so neither tends to stand out. “Copland” and “Tony Copland” are different. Copland is a rare surname, whereas Tony is a common forename, so the surname is a distinctive part. If the goods are identical or closely similar, a conflict is possible. Where a mark combines a business name with a product name, as in BJ’s Matrix, both parts may matter, so each could clash with a mark which uses only “BJ’s” or “Matrix”. Not every word inside a longer mark counts. A word such as POLO inside Royal Berkshire Polo Club would not normally be treated as standing alone because the words work together as a name.

 Key Takeaways and Advice

The key takeaway is always to search before you file. Finding a similar mark early on is far cheaper than facing a conflict later. The goods matter as much as the name. Similar names can clash on similar goods but not on unrelated ones. Look, sound and meaning all count. How customers buy your goods affects which matters the most. Small changes may not avoid a conflict. Customers remember the most distinctive part. Get advice if an earlier owner objects.

The Trademarkroom can search and file your application and review the goods and services you plan to cover. If an objection or a dispute arises, our colleagues at Lawdit Solicitors can help.

share this Article

Recent Articles

trade mark

The Trade Mark Sharks are circling!

Gymshark vs The Conditioning Club: What a David and Goliath Trade Mark Fight Teaches Small Businesses The majority of trademark conflicts do not appear in