...

The Trade Mark Sharks are circling!

Gymshark vs The Conditioning Club: What a David and Goliath Trade Mark Fight Teaches Small Businesses

The majority of trademark conflicts do not appear in national newspapers, but one that was covered by The Guardian this past weekend has affected small company owners all throughout the United Kingdom. The Conditioning Club, an independent gym on an industrial estate in Fairford, Gloucestershire, and Gymshark, the sportswear company that famously began in a family garage and is currently worth at approximately £1 billion, are embroiled in a legal battle before the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO).

The majority of trademark conflicts do not appear in national newspapers, but one that was covered by The Guardian this past weekend has affected small company owners all throughout the United Kingdom. The Conditioning Club, an independent gym on an industrial estate in Fairford, Gloucestershire, and Gymshark, the sportswear company that famously began in a family garage and is currently worth at approximately £1 billion, are embroiled in a legal battle before the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO).

What has happened so far?

The gym has about 500 members, nine employees, and three independent personal trainers. The battle has been going on for about 18 months, and its founder, John Watson, claims that his legal expenses are getting close to £30,000. What makes a name registrable, how oppositions and invalidity cases operate, and what a small business can do when a much larger company takes an interest in its name are some of the most practical concerns in UK trademark law that are at the centre of this case. This is what has transpired and what each and every brand owner may take away from it.

Two distinct instruments are opposition and invalidation.

The distinction between the two primary avenues that the UKIPO tribunal provides for contesting a trademark is significant in this case.

Before an application is registered, it is attacked by an opposition. An application is published in the Trade Marks Journal after the UKIPO has reviewed it. Anyone with an earlier right may object by submitting Form TM7 during this two-month window, which can be extended to three months upon request. According to Section 5 of the Trade Marks Act 1994, the most common justification is that the public is likely to become confused if the new mark is identical or similar to a prior mark for identical or comparable products or services. Mr. Watson employed such strategy to combat Gymshark.

A mark that is already on the register is attacked by an invalidation operation. A registration may be deemed unlawful under section 47 of the Act if it should never have been issued in the first place, for instance, because it lacks unique character (section 3(1)(b)) or merely contains phrases that describe the characteristics of the goods or services (section 3(1)(c)). That is Gymshark’s route against Mr Watson. If an invalidation succeeds, the registration is treated as though it never existed.

The receiving party has two months to submit a defence, or counterstatement, on Form TM8 in both situations. Missing that deadline might have disastrous consequences, such as an application being deemed abandoned and a registration being deemed invalid without any consideration of its merits. If the matter proceeds, the parties exchange evidence before the tribunal makes a decision, either on the papers or following a hearing. Typically, this evidence takes the form of witness statements accompanied by supporting documentation.

Why descriptive names are vulnerable

The core ideas of trade mark usefulness are covered in Gymshark’s argument. A trademark tells consumers not just what a product or service is, but also who makes it. Therefore, the law prohibits any one company from monopolising common phrases that rivals would reasonably must give a description of their goods.

“Club” is a term that gyms frequently use, while “conditioning” is a well-known term in the fitness industry. In the instance of Gymshark, the phrases together only refer to a location where individuals go to perform conditioning exercises. Mr. Watson will probably contend that the UKIPO approved the combination’s registration and that it is a brand unto itself.

An essential safety net is in place. According to Section 47(1), a mark that was registered in violation of the descriptiveness standards will not be deemed invalid if it has since developed a distinctive character for the products or services in question as a result of its use. The owner must provide considerable proof, which can be more difficult than many business owners anticipate. Five years of trading, a devoted membership, and a local reputation may help.

A seeming contradiction has also been brought out by commenters: Gymshark maintains registrations for LIFTING CLUB, the name of its gym concept, which some would argue is equally descriptive. Since the tribunal evaluates each mark on its merits, inconsistency by itself is not a legal defence; rather, it is a point that can influence the parties’ commercial dialogue.

How much does this kind of dispute cost?

Because using the UKIPO tribunal is much less expensive than going to court, it is commonly employed. There is no official price for filing a counterstatement, although there are small official fees for filing an objection or an invalidation application. Professional time spent analysing the opposing side’s case, obtaining evidence, crafting witness testimonies, and submitting legal arguments is the true expense. The alleged price of almost £30,000 for Mr. Watson demonstrates how rapidly things may go up when a case is contested on multiple fronts.

Typically, the tribunal uses a published scale to award costs to the winning party. These prizes, which usually range from a few hundred to a few thousand pounds, are intended as a contribution toward expenses rather than full repayment. That cuts both ways: it reduces the exposure of the losing party, but the winner seldom gets all of its expenditures back.

It is also important to keep in mind that trading under a name is not prohibited under the UKIPO. A company is not required to rename only because it lost a registration or an opposition. However, losing a registration eliminates a useful defence and may make a company more vulnerable in the event that the opposing party files a lawsuit alleging infringement or passing-off.

Seven things small business owners should know

Regardless of the result, every SME that has established or is developing a brand can learn several important lessons from this dispute:

Sign up in advance. Mr. Watson has a point of contention because of his registration. Without it, he would have to rely on the law of passing off, which is typically more difficult and costly to prove.

Select a unique name. A name is less effective as a trademark the more it explains what you do. The strongest protection comes from invented words or common words utilised in novel ways.

Consider more than just your primary service. Consider insuring those products and services from the outset if you intend to conduct events, operate an online store, or sell branded apparel. As was the case here, adding them subsequently results in a new application, which may be objected.

Maintain proof of use. Press coverage, social media activity, membership numbers, turnover statistics, and dated marketing materials can all be used to demonstrate that your name has come to be connected with your company.

Keep an eye on the registration. When a similar mark is published, a trademark watching service notifies you so you may take action during the opposition window instead of realising a problem too late.

Make use of the cooling-off time. In an opposition, both sides may consent to a cooling-off period for negotiations, which may be prolonged to a maximum of 18 months. Narrowed specifications and coexistence agreements frequently settle disagreements without a verdict.

Do not ever miss a deadline. Tribunal deadlines are stringent, and you risk losing your case by default if you do not submit a counterstatement on time.

The larger picture

Any company may contest a registration that it believes to be invalid, and the tribunal will make a decision based on the evidence and the law rather than the size of the parties. The disagreement, however, draws attention to the unequal resources that independent companies must contend with in order to compete with bigger companies that have substantially more financial support.

Preparation is the best defence. If a challenge ever arises, you will be in the best possible position if you have a unique name, a well-written registration that covers the direction your firm is going, and solid documentation of how you use your brand.

Facing a trademark opposition, or worried that your registration could be challenged? TrademarkRoom can check the strength of your brand, file a registration that covers where your business is going, and help you respond to oppositions and invalidity actions. Contact us at tmr@trademarkroom.com or call 023 8000 0190 for a no-obligation chat.

share this Article

Recent Articles